OOIDA’s Spencer outlines hardships truckers face at House hearing
June 12, 2019
In order to fix a broken trucking industry, Congress must first recognize the vital role of truck drivers, OOIDA President Todd Spencer told a U.S. House of Representatives subcommittee.
Spencer served as one of eight witnesses for the Highways and Transit subcommittee hearing titled “Under Pressure: The State of Trucking in America” on Wednesday, June 12, in Washington, D.C.
“Unfortunately, trucking has been fundamentally broken for years, and conditions show little sign of improving,” Spencer said.
“Until Congress understands the most important component in trucking is the driver, very little will change. The next steps you must take are clear – help make trucking an appealing, safe and sustainable career.”
The subcommittee spent about three hours listening to the witnesses’ testimony and discussing the trucking industry’s most pressing issues. Joining Spencer on the panel were Cathy Chase, president of Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety; Chris Spear, president of American Trucking Associations; LaMont Byrd, director of the health and safety department for the International Brotherhood of Teamsters; Jason Craig, director of government affairs for C.H. Robinson Worldwide Inc.; Rodney Noble, senior director of transportation global procurement for PepsiCo; Deputy Chief Mark Savage of the Colorado Highway Patrol; and Andy Young, a truck safety advocate.
Spencer, who was speaking on behalf of OOIDA’s more than 160,000 members, focused on informing lawmakers about the hardships and challenges truckers face every day and asking Congress to recognize that many current trucking regulations do little or nothing to improve highway safety.
“Our typical members spend 250 nights or more away from home and family each year,” Spencer said. “They deal with way too much traffic and congestion and bad and unpredictable weather while working around the schedules of all others in the supply chain.”
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median pay for heavy-duty truck drivers was $43,680 in 2018. While that equals $21 per hour based on a typical 40-hour workweek, it must be noted that it is not uncommon for a trucker to work 80 hours in a week. As truck drivers are exempt from overtime pay, hourly rate for an 80-hour week drops to $10.50.
“There is a growing recognition that the way drivers are compensated – by the load or mile, not by the hour – is a problem,” said Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton, D-D.C. “Drivers face increased pressure to deliver goods … many factors are beyond their control. For example, congested roads and delays and shipper facilities.”
In direct relation to driver pay, detention time is a big issue for truck drivers. Many truck drivers spend hours every week waiting to be loaded or unloaded while receiving no compensation for that time.
“It is a monstrous problem that has actually cost trucking as much as $3 billion a year,” Spencer said. “The way it works out it means that driver workweeks are always going to be 70-80 hours and sometimes more. They are not always working all of those hours, but their time is being controlled by others. The biggest bandits are shippers and receivers, and I should point out that some of them actually have the gall to charge drivers for late deliveries.”
Young added that detention time can lead to negative safety outcomes.
“The detention time issue is really key,” he said. “The shippers and receivers aren’t regulated like the truck driver. So, ultimately, the shippers and receivers can abuse the entire federal motor carrier safety regulatory code and then escape liability.”
Chase recently received a firsthand account of the problem.
“It struck me as I went on a ride-along and we were sitting there waiting for the load to arrive and be loaded, that I was getting paid and the driver was not,” she said. “There was some irony there.”
Spencer expressed to lawmakers that more regulations do not lead to more safety on the highways. At one point, Spencer picked up a copy of the 700-page Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations Handbook to give lawmakers an idea about how many regulations truck drivers are forced to follow. However, the regulations have not led to a decrease in fatal crashes. Spencer used the electronic logging mandate as an example. In January, a preliminary study revealed that the ELD mandate has not reduced crashes.
“Looking at what the data shows, there is a disconnect between compliance with the regulations and improved safety outcomes,” Spencer said. “Most of the regulations that are enforced that make up CSA (Compliance, Safety, Accountability scores) have nothing to do with safety, but that has been the focus.
“The rigidity of the regulations sometimes force drivers to do things they don’t want to do.”
Several members of the panel agreed that increasing pay is a good place to start in the effort to keep experienced and safe drivers on the road. The turnover rate for large motor carriers has consistently been 90% or more.
“The reasons drivers stay is because of pay, benefits and working conditions,” Spencer said. “The reasons they leave are for the lack thereof. Many of the regulations that are on the books today hold drivers for everything that could possibly go wrong, but none of those really address the frustrations the lost time that drivers will spend in shipping and receiving facilities. We’re talking about anywhere from 10 to 45 hours per week. That puts the work week for a truck driver to 80 or sometimes more hours a week.
“When someone is considering a career, do they take one that works 40-45 hours a week and you’re home or one that’s 80 hours or more with you being away from home and you don’t make more money? I don’t think that’s a real tough decision … We have to address the economic issues for drivers, how they are paid and the quirks that allow them to work unlimited hours without any kind of overtime compensation.”